The letter had read:
“Dear Holbrook Family,
For your contribution in the downfall of Oak Hill, you are cursed.
However, I have generously decided to give your family one last chance to undo the curse. Reunite at your family estate on Friday at 8pm, one week from today. Choose one among you to live forever with the curse, and the rest of you will be free of it, or you will all live with the curse as you quarrel until your final days. You will have until midnight to decide and speak it in unison.
You will not understand the nature of the curse until the clock strikes midnight. There will be no second chances.
To the future you deserve. Cheers.”
The gray stone mansion at the top of Oak Hill was dimly lit by candlelight and the occasional flash of lightening. Mature trees obscured the view of the old home from the rest of the town. Heavy rainfall drenched the estate as the last member of the Holbrook family pulled onto the expansive cobblestone driveway, just in time.
The grand entrance led to an exquisitely decorated parlor, covered in a telltale layer of dust. White furniture covers lay on the white marble floor where seating had been uncovered for use. Rich mahogany columns flanked the doorway with an intricately carved pattern of native flora and fauna. A chaise joined a mahogany bookcase in a corner by the bay window, where a cushioned bench beckoned anyone who entered the room. A deep maroon leather couch and matching recliners framed a seating area in front of the lit stone fireplace.
“Do you understand what will happen if we can’t come to an agreement?” Uncle James gritted through his teeth. Aunt Willa, his wife, rolled her eyes. It had been no small miracle to get everyone to agree to this meeting, letter or no letter.
“Don’t talk down to me. We all know why we’re here.” My cousin and Uncle James’ daughter, Marlena, snapped back. Her belly wrenched with the movement of her unborn baby as her irritation grew. Her husband, Martin, placed his hand over hers in quiet solidarity.
“I’m here.” My father, William, strolled in the front door into the parlor. He shook his hand through his hair to dispel from of the cold rainwater. My mother, Charlotte, was praying silently on the window bench. She stiffened at my father’s arrival but did not look up.
“Has anyone volunteered?” William looked to his brother, James. Thunder roared in response to the blue-white flash that preceded it.
My brother, Garrett, scoffed, prompting James to snap, “Unless you’re volunteering, save the fucking sarcasm.”
“Why don’t you volunteer?” I retorted, with an edge in my tone. “It certainly can’t be Marlena; she’s pregnant.” I waved in her general direction.
The room erupted in a fury of shouting and bickering, each person angling to save themselves. Each person, except for my mother. The only thing anyone could agree on was that it couldn’t be Marlena.
“Stop.” Charlotte said quietly. No one turned. “STOP!” The thunder boomed in punctuation to my mother’s cry. Everyone turned to her, gaping at her sudden assertiveness. Other than Marlena’s unborn child, my mother probably deserved this the least. I would volunteer before anyone tried to choose her.
“Something to say, Char?” James raised an eyebrow. William strained to extinguish his irritation.
“No one here is going to give their own name in unison with the others. At best, we could get a 7 to 1 vote. We may as well accept our fate now.” She turned back to the window, watching the trees bend in the wind as streams ran down the glass. Her suggestion was met with apprehensive silence. Her prayers resumed.
The grandfather clock chimed 8pm.
My skin itched. I looked around and found the others were scratching their forearms, necks, or hands. The first symptom of the curse, I assumed. A rush of panic sent shivers down my spine. I didn’t dare vocalize my suspicions. The fighting would only intensify.
“Spencer, who do you think should be chosen?” My brother asked me quietly, his forefinger subtly scratching his wrist. I looked him up and down and said nothing.
The first hour passed in relative silence, everyone seemingly accepting Charlotte’s assessment. I winced when the grandfather clock struck 9pm. I wondered if another symptom would appear. I glanced around the room with relief as no one else seemed to feel the dull pain I noticed building in my back and shoulders.
My mother’s whispered pleas were barely audible above the crackling in the fireplace. Time ticked away and each of us made our arguments as to why they shouldn’t be chosen: baby on the way, too young, too necessary at work, and so on. Then James added that this mess wasn’t his fault, with a pointed look to William, and the room erupted again. Amidst the arguing, Martin moved to a seat on the floor, his back to the fire, shifting around as he attempted to regain some comfort. He was rubbing his back.
The grandfather clock struck 10pm.
The third symptom caught everyone’s attention, spurring fresh panic as the reality began to sink in. It felt like knives in my hands, yet no protrusion was present. I looked for the source of the pain, but to no avail. It felt like it was coming from inside my skin.
“It’s starting, isn’t it?” Willa’s face contorted in pain as she looked at the back of her hands.
Behind her, Marlena laid her arms across her belly, holding the life inside her and hoping the baby wasn’t part of this. Garrett struck a match and lit a cigarette. James rummaged through the liquor cabinet and poured a four-knuckle glass of scotch.
“If no one will volunteer, why don’t we draw straws?” Martin chimed in, adding, “Leave Marlena out of it.”
I responded, “If it will end this faster, then fine. I don’t particularly want to go through any more symptoms unless I have to.” Nods of agreement.
Martin grabbed some stirrer straws from the liquor cabinet and found a knife to cut one in half. “Marlena, since you’re not in this, you mix up the straws and hold them.” She complied.
One by one, we each drew a long straw until only two remained. James and William stared at the final straws. James hesitated and then drew his straw – cut in half. The room was a mix of horror at James’ fate and relief at their own.
“The letter said we have to say the name in unison, so are we ready?” Marlena rushed.
Staring at the ill-fated straw, James said, “I...I can’t be the one. I shouldn’t be. This isn’t fair.” His voice began to rise in panic with each sentence. “William is the one who started all this. If he had any honor, he would shoulder this burden!”
The room fell uneasily silent. A flash, then thunder. “Honor?” William said quietly, but forcefully. “Honor?! If anyone lacks honor, it’s you. You forced my hand after dad died. You cornered me into decisions I didn’t want to make. And when it all went to hell, you ran. Like a fucking coward, you ran. It’s no surprise you’re using what you set in motion – what you forced me to be a part of – to twist this around on me. For once in your life, YOU have some honor.”
“I won’t say my name.” All eyes on him. “‘in unison.’” James mockingly air quoted, his biting tone reigniting dread in the rest of us as, yet again, we had no answer.
Marlena wiped a silent tear from her eye and my mother resumed her prayers by the window. Rage flickered in William’s eyes as James sat down and continued nursing his scotch, not daring to look my father in the eye. Garrett met my gaze and dropped it, knowing which side we’d each taken in the family war. I wished I could tell him that I would go back and change things if I could.
The grandfather clock struck 11pm.
Everyone turned to each other expectantly. The fourth symptom struck our mouths – a piercing pain in our gums like none of us had ever experienced. The previous symptoms intensified, bringing some of us to our knees. James’ scotch glass shattered against the marble as thunder rumbled outside.
“We should just try to say James’ name together anyway. See if it works.” Marlena pushed. Her fear was palpable. Murmurs of agreement followed.
James’ eyes shot daggers at his daughter and wife. “You’ve gotta be fucking kidding me.”
“We have less than an hour. I’m not going to live with whatever this curse is for the rest of my life because you’re a coward.” Willa snapped.
“You gold-digging whore.” James grabbed the bottle of scotch and took a swig.
I laughed derisively. “Wow.”
“Let’s not forget that some of the choices William made were all his own idea. I may have played a part in contriving some of the situations, but he is just as much at fault as I am.”
“We’re all to blame, in some way or another.” My mother spoke up. “We probably deserve this.” She added quietly.
“I’m not going out like this.” Willa retorted. “Come on, we have to try.”
All of us, aside from James, gathered in front of the fireplace. “We choose James.”
Nothing happened.
Nothing, except the symptoms continued to increase in intensity. It dawned on me what we were facing, what the nature of the curse would be. My heart pounded, adrenaline filled my veins as if it would take on a life of its own and burst out of me.
“Fuck all of you.” James raised the bottle, tipping it in mock tribute before taking another swig.
The pain was growing, my bones felt like they might snap under the pressure. Thunder roared in tune with a bright flash. The wind and rain increased, drowning out my mother’s continued prayers as she strained to fight the symptoms. We huddled near her in solidarity for her pleas, gripping each other’s shoulders in support. James sat in agony with his scotch, alone.
The grandfather clock struck midnight. We waited, but nothing happened. The bottle of scotch slipped from James’ limp hand and broke open on the floor.
I never should have taken James’ side all those years ago. That selfish bastard was never going to accept his fate, but I wouldn’t let him ruin my life a second time. While everyone else joined my mother by the window, I took the knife Martin used to cut the straw and jammed it into James’ trachea. I joined my family by the window and convinced them to say his name together again, as one last ditch effort, minutes before midnight.
The symptoms faded. We sighed in echo of the relief we felt. Willa was the first to notice James. She screamed in shock. Marlena nearly fainted. To my surprise, James’ eyes opened. They had a new glow about them. He turned toward us, and the transformation began.
Screams. Then silence.