Tatum woke up to the sound of her alarm, the sun barely peeking through her bedroom curtains. She stretched and sat up, allowing her eyes to adjust.
She grabbed her outfit for the school day. After getting dressed, she shuffled over to her vanity mirror, which reflected a girl who looked older than her thirteen years. With long blonde hair, bright emerald eyes, and plump pink lips, Tatum was undeniably beautiful.
She brushed her hair and began applying her makeup, enjoying the quiet routine of the morning. As she finished, she admired her reflection, pleased with how she looked. Her room, decorated in various shades of pink, looked like any other teenage girl's space. She smiled to herself, feeling a surge of contentment. Her mom had worked hard to provide for her, especially since her father had bailed on them when Tatum was just a baby. Her life may not have been perfect, but she was loved and well taken care of. And in her eyes, that’s all that mattered.
With one final glance around her cozy room, she checked her reflection once more and headed downstairs for breakfast. Suddenly, a loud banging on the front door shattered the peaceful morning. Tatum frowned. They rarely had visitors. "Hm, that’s odd," she thought. "I wonder who that could be."
She was halfway down the stairs when she heard a booming voice from outside. "FBI, open up!" Tatum's heart leaped into her throat. She covered her mouth, her pulse quickening. What on earth was the FBI doing at their house?
Sally, her mother, appeared at the bottom of the stairs, her face pale. "Shhh!" she mouthed, putting a finger to her lips. She rushed up the stairs, staying as quiet as she could, before grabbing Tatum's hand and ushering her back up the steps. "Mom, what is going on? Why are the cops here?" Tatum asked, her voice trembling.
Sally didn’t answer. She dragged Tatum into her bedroom and shoved her into the closet, huddling close to her. Tears streamed down Sally’s face as she held her daughter tightly. "Honey, listen to me really closely. Mama loves you so, so much. Nothing will ever change that." She paused, exhaling deeply as if to compose herself. "You may not see Mama for a while," she continued. "But I promise you, nothing will ever change the fact that I love you with all of my heart."
Tatum stared at her mother, confusion and fear battling for dominance. "Mom, please tell me what’s going on. Why are you saying all this?"
Before Sally could respond, they heard the front door crash open. Heavy footsteps thudded through the house. Sally began to sob, her grip on Tatum tightening. "Oh God, they’re coming. They’re going to take you from me now. Please don’t be scared. Be strong for Mama. I love you so much, baby girl."
The bedroom door was kicked off its hinges, and several agents stormed in, their faces grim. They found Sally and Tatum in the closet. One agent grabbed Sally and yanked her to her feet, forcing her hands behind her back. "Monica Gonzales, you’re under arrest for kidnapping."
Tatum's world tilted. "Monica? Who is Monica? Her name is Sally! And Kidnapping? Who did she kidnap?" she cried as her eyes widened in horror. The panicked questions tumbled from her lips – all of which continued to go unanswered.
Sally hung her head, her face guilt-ridden and soaked with tears. "I am so sorry. I love you so much," she said as they led her away.
Another agent gently helped Tatum out of the closet. "Honey, we have to take you down to the station for some questioning."
Tatum shook her head, hot tears and surrealism blurring her vision. "What’s happening? Where are you taking my mom? She didn’t do anything wrong!" she choked, wringing her hands nervously. "She would never kidnap anybody! I’m the only kid she’s ever had, and she’s raised me all on her own! I don’t have anybody else, you can’t take her from me!"
The agent avoided her gaze, and Tatum felt a sickening dread settle in the pit of her stomach. Something was terribly wrong, but she couldn’t grasp what it was.
At the station, Tatum was led into a small, stark room. She sat at a metal table, her hands trembling. A female detective entered, her expression kind but serious. She had dark hair pulled into a tight bun and sharp, intelligent eyes.
"Hi, Tatum. I’m Detective Galonsky," she said, sitting across from her. "I know you’re scared and confused right now, but I need you to listen carefully."
Tatum nodded, her throat tight. "What’s going on? Where’s my mom?" she asked softly, wiping her nose with her sleeve.
Detective Galonsky took a deep breath, as if mentally preparing for the news she was about to deliver sliding a box of tissues across the table. "Tatum, the woman you know as your mother, Sally, is actually Monica Gonzales. Thirteen years ago, she kidnapped you from a hospital in the United States. Your real name is Samantha Howard. You are the daughter of James and Brenda Howard. Your birth parents have been looking for you ever since."
Tatum's mind reeled. She stared at the detective, wide-eyed and open-mouthed. She glanced around the small room, as if half expecting someone to jump out laughing and say, “just kidding!” But nobody ever did. Tatum's mouth opened and closed as she struggled to find words. Finally, she mustered a strained whisper. "No, that’s not possible. She’s my mom. She’s always been my mom."
"I know this is hard to understand, but Monica—Sally—kidnapped you when you were just a baby. She fled to Canada and created new identities for both of you. Your real parents have never stopped searching for you. For 13 years, they insisted that you were still out there somewhere and they never gave up hope."
Tatum shook her head, tears streaming down her face. "No, this can’t be true. She’s my mom. She’s always been my mom."
Detective Galonsky reached out, but Tatum recoiled, her eyes blazing with anger. "No! I want to see my mom!" she screamed, her voice choked with fear and desperation. "You people have no idea what you’re talking about! You’ve made a huge mistake!"
The detective's face softened, but she didn't back down. "I’m so sorry, Tatum. I know this is a lot to take in. But your parents are on their way here. They’ve never given up hope of finding you."
Tatum’s world shattered. She felt like she was falling into a bottomless pit. "This is a nightmare. This is a bad, bad nightmare, and I'm going to wake up any minute," she thought, desperately. But as the news sank in, she knew that it was a harsh reality – one from which there was no escape.
Her anger dissipated, replaced by a profound sense of loss. Suddenly, she looked a lot younger than normal. She looked like a lost and broken little girl, a fragile thing sitting across from the detective, as if she might crumble right there in her seat. She clutched at her hair, rocking back and forth, her knees drawn tightly to her chest. "No, no, no! I want my mama! Please! This is a mistake! She’s my mom! She’s always been my mom!" She repeated the words again and again, as if saying them over and over would somehow magically make them true.
Detective Galonsky watched, her heart breaking for the young girl. She stepped out of the room and joined a colleague, another female officer with compassionate eyes.
"God, this is such a shame," the colleague said. "Poor girl has been a prisoner her entire life."
Detective Galonsky sighed deeply, her hazel eyes full of sadness. "Can one even be considered a prisoner if they are unaware of their captivity?"